• 5 minute read
When Less Is Not More: The Effect of Empty Space on Persuasion
By Fang Ying, Senior Writer, China Business Knowledge @ CUHK
Empty space or white space has been widely used in advertising and interior design to give the feeling of a clean and elegant look. ‘Less is more’ is the message in the modern world. However, will ‘more’space become ‘less’ effective in communication?
Only a few empirical studies have investigated the effect of empty space on consumer behavior, and the findings are not clear and sometimes contradictive. For instance, a previous study found that surrounding the picture of a product by empty space increases perceptions of the product’s prestige value, thereby increasing evaluations of the product. However, other research suggest that the empty space surrounding a verbal message could draw people’s attention away from the message and decrease the resources they devote to processing it, and thereby decreasing the message’s impact.
In a recent study, Prof. Dai Xianchi, Associate Professor of the Department of Marketing at CUHK Business School, further looked into the effect of empty space on persuasion. The study was carried out alongside his collaborators, Prof. Robert Wyer, Visiting professor of the same department and university, and PhD student Canice Kwan, now Assistant Professor at Sun Yat-sen University.
“People’s construal of the implications of a message goes beyond its literal meaning and the white space that surrounds a text message can affect the message’s persuasiveness,” says Prof. Dai.
The researchers proposed that when a verbal statement is surrounded by empty space, it activates more general concepts that there is room for doubt to the validity or importance of the message content.
“In other words, the statement is less persuasive when it is surrounded by empty space than when it is not,” Prof. Dai points out.
The Studies and Results
Seven studies in both laboratory and real-life settings were conducted.
In one study, the team collected 115 images of statements posted on a Facebook page over a one-month period from November to December in 2013, and downloaded a screenshot of each message image to record the amount of space (its image size and text space), audience responses (the total number of likes, shares, and comments), and the presence of non-text elements (a picture of a cartoon character and celebrities, nature scene background, etc.). At the same time, they used the numbers of likes, shares and comments as the indicators of effectiveness.
The results showed that individuals’ likings for the statements decreased as the amount of empty space increased. In other words, the impact of a statement decreases when it is surrounded by empty space.
In another study, 126 Hong Kong undergraduate students performed several marketing studies that were unrelated to the experiment. After that, the researchers announced that they could take away copies of the research paper related to the studies on a table next to the exit.
The copies were placed next to two pasteboards, each with a note that says “PICK ME!”.
The text, font size and type of the note were exactly the same, but the pasteboards were in two different sizes and conditions: A4 size with empty space surrounding the text, and A5 size with limited space surrounding the text.
The results revealed that more students (59.6%) picked up the papers in limited space condition than those printed in the empty space condition (37.7%).
“It indicates that participants complied less with the message’s implication when the message was surrounded by substantial empty space,” Prof. Dai says.
“In political campaigns, a candidate may want to present his messages in limited space rather than empty space to convey his messages more effectively.” – Prof. Dai Xianchi
To examine whether the amount of space surrounding a persuasive message would influence recipients’ opinions when the message was generated randomly by a computer or intentionally by the communicator, another study was performed.
This time, 266 US participants were asked to evaluate two popular quotes from the Internet that emphasized the importance of personal warmth: ‘Hold on to whatever keeps you warm inside’ and ‘A kind word can warm three winter months’. Each quote was presented in either a box with little empty space or a box with substantial empty space.
Unlike in other studies, a headline was also added at the top of each quote. In the condition where the message was randomly generated, the headline stated: ‘The message and the configuration of the image (e.g., font, color, or other visuals) do not reflect the personal attitude or intention of the author’. On the other hand, in the condition where the quote reflected the personal attitude or intention of the author, the headline read: ‘The message and the configuration of the image are the result of the author’s free choice’.
In each case, participants were asked to rate the persuasiveness of each statement along three questions: ‘To what extent do you like the quote?’; ‘To what extent do you think the quote is important?’; and ‘To what extent do you agree with the quote?’, from a scale of 1 (not at all) to 7 (very much). They also had to report their perceptions on how strongly the quote conveyed its opinion and the time they took to make their evaluation was recorded.
As predicted, the results showed that when the message was generated intentionally by the communicator, participants perceived it to convey a non-significantly weaker opinion when there was substantial empty space than when there was little empty space.
“That is to say, empty space should not influence the persuasiveness of the message if readers believed that the configuration of space and message was generated randomly by a computer,” said Prof. Dai.
“Our experiment suggested that people infer the strength of statement from the design – whether the statement is surrounded by empty space or full space,” he continued.
“This study demonstrates how visual clues, in particular empty space, affect the impact of verbal messages. All our results have shown people find a message less persuasive when it is surrounded by empty space than when it is not,” says Prof. Dai.
“This offers practical insights on advertising and even in political campaigns. For example, a candidate may want to present his messages in limited space rather than empty space to convey his messages more effectively,” says Prof. Dai.